Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength Bourbon 750ML

Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength Bourbon 750ML is a cask-strength bourbon finished in freshly toasted oak barrels, bottled at 750ml with proof varying by batch (typically 100–116 proof / 50–58% ABV). The Penelope Barrel Strength expression earned a Double Gold medal and 96 points at the 2024 San Francisco World Spirits Competition, cementing the brand's reputation among serious bourbon drinkers.

Quick Facts: ABV: Varies by batch (50–58%)  |  Origin: Lawrenceburg, Indiana, USA  |  Aged 4–5 Years, Toasted Barrel Finish  |  Distillery: MGP (Midwest Grain Products)

Production & Heritage

Penelope Bourbon sources its whiskey from MGP in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, one of the most prolific and respected contract distilleries in American whiskey. The base spirit uses a high-rye mashbill of 74% corn, 21% rye, and 5% malted barley, aged four to five years in charred new American oak barrels before undergoing a secondary finish in new, freshly toasted barrels. What distinguishes each batch is the deliberate variation in char levels (#1 through #5) and toast levels (light, medium, or heavy), meaning no two batches share the exact same flavor fingerprint — a deliberate approach that rewards repeat exploration.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: The nose opens with warm honey and vanilla bean, then develops into caramel and a bright lemon peel accent. Underneath, brown sugar and a subtle flash of hot cherry pepper add complexity as the proof asserts itself.

Taste: The palate enters thick and coating, with an immediate wave of cinnamon spice reminiscent of Red Hots candy alongside rich vanilla and honey. Mid-palate, toasted oak and lemongrass emerge, while the high rye content pushes baking spice and a peppery bite that builds steadily toward peak intensity.

Finish: The finish is moderate in length with lingering brown sugar, cracked black pepper, and a light char-smoke quality. A toasted grain sweetness persists, keeping the bourbon warm without turning harsh despite the elevated proof.

How to Drink Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength

At cask strength, a few drops of water open up the toasted oak and honey notes significantly — start neat to gauge the batch proof, then add water incrementally. For cocktails, the robust proof and spiced character hold up exceptionally well: try it in an Old Fashioned, where the cinnamon and brown sugar notes align naturally with bitters and a citrus peel; in a Boulevardier, where the toasted oak and rye spice stand up to Campari's bitterness; or in a Gold Rush, where honey syrup amplifies the bourbon's existing honey backbone without masking the barrel finish.

Best For

• Bourbon collectors exploring batch variation and toasted barrel finishes
• Gifting a whiskey enthusiast who already owns the standard Penelope expressions
• Side-by-side tastings comparing toasted versus charred barrel influence
• Building barrel-proof cocktails that demand a bourbon with backbone and spice

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength taste like? It delivers a bold combination of cinnamon spice, vanilla, honey, and toasted oak, with a thick mouthfeel and noticeable rye-driven pepper that builds through the sip. The toasted barrel finish adds a brown sugar sweetness that tempers the barrel-proof heat.

How does Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength compare to Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel? Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel is bottled at 94 proof and uses a lower-rye mashbill, resulting in a softer, more caramel-forward profile. Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength runs significantly hotter (100–116 proof) and leans spicier thanks to its 21% rye content and batch-variable toast levels.

Is Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength good for sipping neat? Yes, though the batch proof can range up to 116 proof, so tasters sensitive to heat may want a splash of water. The toasted barrel finish provides enough sweetness and depth to reward careful neat exploration.

Where is Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength made? The bourbon is distilled at MGP (Midwest Grain Products) in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, and is finished and blended under the Penelope Bourbon brand. Lawrenceburg sits along the Ohio River in southeastern Indiana, a region with a long distilling heritage.

What foods pair well with Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength? Smoked brisket or pulled pork complements the toasted oak and brown sugar character. Dark chocolate with sea salt plays against the cinnamon spice. Aged cheddar or Gruyère matches the honey and caramel sweetness. Pecan pie echoes the toasted nut and vanilla notes. Cinnamon-spiced bread pudding mirrors the bourbon's baking spice profile.

What sizes does Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength come in? The standard release is a 750ml bottle, which is the most widely available format for this expression.

Is Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength worth the price? It positions as a premium barrel-proof offering and competes directly with other toasted-finish and barrel-strength bourbons in its tier. The batch-to-batch variation in char and toast levels adds collectibility, and the Double Gold recognition at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition supports its standing as strong value within the barrel-proof category.

Why Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength?

The deliberate rotation of char levels (#1–#5) and toast levels (light, medium, heavy) across batches gives this bourbon something rare in the category: genuine batch-to-batch uniqueness backed by a consistent quality floor. The high-rye mashbill at barrel proof delivers a spice intensity that most toasted-finish competitors at lower proof simply cannot match. Recognition at the 2024 San Francisco World Spirits Competition with a Double Gold medal and 96 points validates the approach. For drinkers who want a toasted bourbon that refuses to play it safe, this expression delivers proof-forward complexity without sacrificing the caramel-and-vanilla accessibility that draws people to the toasted barrel category in the first place.