The Best Rye Whiskey: Our Picks for a Manhattan, a Sazerac and Sipping Neat
The best rye whiskey for a Manhattan, a Sazerac and sipping neat, plus the difference between 95% rye and Kentucky-style rye.
★ 4.5 · 1,700+ Google Reviews
Family-Owned Since 1982
Family-owned in Chicago's North Shore since 1982. Bourbon, tequila, scotch, wine and craft beer, delivered to your door.
Johnnie Walker
Johnnie Walker Black Label 1.75L
Don Julio
Johnnie Walker
Johnnie Walker Blue Label 750ML
Veuve Clicquot
Veuve Clicquot Brut Yellow Label
The Prisoner Wine Company
The Prisoner Napa Valley Red Blend
Hotel Starlino
Starlino Maraschino Cherries 14.1 OZ
Hotel Starlino
Hotel Starlino Orange Aperitivo 750ML
8 PM
8 PM Grain Blended Whisky 750ML
Hotel Starlino
Hotel Starlino Rose Aperitivo 750ML
Ruggeri Argeo
Laya
Laya Reposado Black Edition 750ML
Glenlivet
Glenlivet Founders Reserve 1.75L
Headframe
Headframe Orphan Girl Bourbon Cream Liqueur 750ML
Johnnie Walker
Johnnie Walker Black Label 1.75L
Score
Score Reposado Mexico Limited Edition 750ML
Buffalo Trace Distillery
A refined VSOP cognac from Maison Rouge, crafted in France and aged in oak for smooth depth and balance. Elegant notes of vanilla, dried fruit, warm spice, and toasted oak lead into a mellow, rounded finish. A classic 750ml bottle perfect for sipping neat, over ice, or elevating timeless cocktails.
Maison Rouge VSOP Cognac 750ML requires extra processing time and will ship as soon as it is back in stock.
The best rye whiskey for a Manhattan, a Sazerac and sipping neat, plus the difference between 95% rye and Kentucky-style rye.
VS vs. VSOP vs. XO explained, plus the best cognac for each job: Ferrand 1840 for a Sidecar, Rémy Martin and Hine VSOP to sip, Cordon Bleu and Rémy XO...
The best herbal liqueurs for sipping and for cocktails like the Last Word and Vieux Carré: Green and Yellow Chartreuse, Bénédictine, Strega, génépy, Galliano and absinthe compared.
The best amaretto for an Amaretto Sour, for sipping and for coffee: Disaronno, Lazzaroni, Gozio, Villa Massa and Luxardo compared, with our picks and FAQ.
Our flagship guide to rakija: the best plum slivovitz, grape lozova, quince dunja and apricot kajsija from Serbia, Croatia, Bulgaria, North Macedonia and the Czech Republic, and how it's traditionally...
The best orange liqueurs for margaritas, Sidecars and sipping, from Cointreau and Grand Marnier to Pierre Ferrand Dry Curaçao and Combier. We explain triple sec vs curaçao and pick a...
The best rum to sip, for a mojito or daiquiri and for a Mai Tai, plus spiced, agricole and value picks, with every rum style explained.
The best cream liqueurs for coffee, dessert and holiday gifting, from Baileys and Five Farms Irish cream to RumChata, bourbon cream and Tequila Rose. Our picks, compared side by side.
Room for one more. Shipping is per box, not per bottle.
Family-owned since 1982, The Liquor Barn has three stores across Chicago's North Shore in Wheeling, Niles, and Vernon Hills. We carry over 17,000 wines, spirits, and beers — and we ship nationwide. Most orders go out same day with tracking.
Visit one of our Illinois locations or shop online today.