The Best Allocated Bourbon: The Bottles Worth Buying When You See Them
"Do you have any Blanton's?" is a question every bourbon counter hears. Allocated bourbon is real, it is scarce, and it is worth understanding before you chase it. This guide explains what allocated actually means, how bottles get from the distillery to a store shelf, and which allocated and hard-to-find bourbons are worth your money when we have them.
In This Guide
- Our Picks at a Glance
- Allocated Bourbon, Compared
- What Does Allocated Bourbon Mean?
- Best Allocated Bourbon Under $75
- Best Allocated Single Barrel Bourbon
- Best Barrel Proof Allocated Bourbon
- Best Aged and Limited Releases
- Great Bourbon That Drinks Like It's Allocated
- How to Drink an Allocated Bottle
- Frequently Asked Questions
Our Picks at a Glance
Allocated stock moves fast. Every bottle below was on our shelf when we wrote this, but treat the list as "when we have it." The product page always shows what is in stock right now.
- Best allocated bourbon to start with: Weller Special Reserve. The wheated Buffalo Trace bottle everyone learns on.
- Best allocated bourbon under $75: Colonel E.H. Taylor, Jr. Small Batch. Bottled in bond at 100 proof.
- Best allocated bourbon for a gift: Blanton's Single Barrel. The horse stopper still makes people smile.
- Best age statement for the money: Eagle Rare 10 Year.
- Best cask strength allocated bourbon: Cream of Kentucky Cask Strength.
- Best allocated store pick: Old Forester Liquor Barn Single Barrel Barrel Proof, our own barrel.
- Best allocated rye for a bourbon drinker: Woodford Reserve Barrel Strength Rye.
- Best hard-to-find bourbon that isn't from Buffalo Trace: Old Fitzgerald 7 Year Bottled in Bond.
Allocated Bourbon, Compared
Proof is what the producer or our product page lists for the bottle we sell. Single barrel and barrel proof bottles change, so we say "varies" where they do. Price tiers reflect our current shelf price; the product page has the exact number.
| Bottle | Style / Region | Proof | Flavor | Price tier | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weller Special Reserve | Wheated, Buffalo Trace | 90 | Honey, vanilla, soft bread | $30 to $50 | First allocated bottle |
| E.H. Taylor Small Batch | Bottled in bond, Buffalo Trace | 100 | Caramel, baking spice, firm oak | $50 to $75 | Everyday allocated pour |
| Eagle Rare 10 Year | 10 year, Buffalo Trace | 90 | Toffee, orange peel, leather | $50 to $75 | Age statement value |
| Old Fitzgerald 7 BIB | Wheated, bonded, Heaven Hill | 100 | Brown sugar, toasted bread | $50 to $75 | Wheated fans |
| Cream of Kentucky CS | Cask strength, Kentucky | 106.4 | Caramel, toasted nuts, spice | $75 to $100 | Sipping |
| Old Forester LB Barrel Proof | Single barrel, our pick | Varies by barrel | Dark cherry, toffee, oak | $75 to $100 | Barrel proof fans |
| Blanton's Single Barrel | Single barrel, Buffalo Trace | 93 | Orange, caramel, light spice | $100 to $150 | Gifts |
| Baker's 13 Year | Single barrel, Beam | 107 | Dark caramel, nuts, deep oak | $150 to $250 | Aged bourbon lovers |
| Woodford Barrel Strength Rye | Rye, Kentucky, 700ml | 125.1 | Rye spice, dark fruit, cocoa | $100 to $150 | Rye lovers |
| Orphan Barrel Fanged Pursuit | 17 year, Kentucky | 92 | Old oak, dried fruit, tobacco | $150 to $250 | Aged bourbon fans |
| Kentucky Owl Batch 13 | Limited blend, Kentucky | 113.6 | Dark caramel, cherry, oak | $250 and up | The big splurge |
What Does Allocated Bourbon Mean?
"Allocated" is not a legal term, and you will not find it on a label. It describes how a bottle is sold. When a distiller cannot make enough of a whiskey to meet demand, it divides what it has among its distributors, and each distributor divides its share among the bars and stores it sells to. Every step in that chain gets a slice, not an order.
That is the three-tier system at work. In Illinois, like most states, a distillery sells to a distributor, the distributor sells to a retailer like us, and we sell to you. Distributors decide how to split an allocation, and the method varies by state and by company. Some look at a store's overall sales history with the brand, some use rotations, some use other rules. A retailer cannot simply call up and order more Blanton's.
A few things follow from that:
- Nobody knows exact timing. Shipments arrive when the distributor releases them. We can't promise a specific bottle on a specific day, and you should be wary of anyone who does.
- Quantities are small. Some allocated bottles arrive by the case. The rarest arrive a few bottles at a time, if at all.
- "Allocated" sometimes means "limited." A bottle can be allocated because it is scarce, or simply because it is a small release. Both are real, but they are not the same as a whiskey with a ten-year waiting list.
How allocated bottles show up at The Liquor Barn
When allocated and hard-to-find bottles are in stock, we put them on the site and gather them in our Allocated and Hard to Find collection. That collection is the fastest way to see what we have today. If you want a heads-up on rare releases and our own single barrel picks, sign up at the bottom of our page on how we pick our single barrels.
Best Allocated Bourbon Under $75
These are the bottles most people mean when they say allocated. They are made in real volume, but demand still outruns supply. They are also the best value in the category: excellent whiskey in our under $75 price tiers.
Weller uses wheat instead of rye as its second grain, and Buffalo Trace uses that same wheated mash bill for all of its wheated bourbons, which is why Weller gets compared to the Van Winkle line. At 90 proof, Special Reserve is soft and easy: honey, vanilla and fresh bread with very little spice. A great first allocated bottle and a great pour for people who say bourbon is too hot. Its stronger sibling, Weller Antique 107, is even harder to find.
Named for the distiller who pushed for the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897, and bottled under those rules: one distillery, one distilling season, at least four years old, exactly 100 proof. Caramel, baking spice and firm oak. It tends to be one of the easier Buffalo Trace allocated bottles to find, which makes it one to actually drink instead of just display.
A ten-year age statement on a bottle you can drink every week is rare now. Toffee, orange peel, leather and a dry, gentle oak finish. It is the bottle we suggest to Scotch drinkers who want to see what an older bourbon tastes like.
Heaven Hill's wheated bourbon in a decanter that looks great on a bar cart. Seven years old and bonded at 100 proof, with brown sugar, toasted bread and a rich, round texture. If you love Weller and can't find it, this is where we send you.
Best Allocated Single Barrel Bourbon
Single barrel means every bottle comes from one barrel, not a blend of many. That makes each bottling a little different, which is half the fun. Buffalo Trace also makes Rock Hill Farms and E.H. Taylor Single Barrel, and both arrive in very small numbers. For a deeper dive, see our guide to the best single barrel bourbon, which publishes in December.
Elmer T. Lee introduced Blanton's in 1984, and it is widely credited as the first single barrel bourbon sold commercially. Orange, caramel, vanilla and light spice, with a silky texture at 93 proof. Each stopper carries a horse and jockey in one of eight poses, and collectors try to spell out B-L-A-N-T-O-N-S. It is still the allocated bottle people are happiest to unwrap.
Baker's 13 Year is the older expression of Baker's, aged 13 years and bottled from a single barrel. Dark caramel, toasted nuts and deep oak, with the extra years showing up as a longer, drier finish. A good pick for someone who already loves Knob Creek and wants the next step up.
Our own private barrel selection from Old Forester's single barrel program, bottled at full strength. The exact proof varies by barrel; our product page lists roughly 128 to 134 proof or more. Toffee, dark cherry and brown sugar with a creamy texture. Every barrel is one of a kind. Add water.
Another of our own picks: a ten-year, high-rye Kentucky bourbon from independent bottler Rare Character, non-chill filtered and bottled at barrel proof. Mature oak, caramel and a long baking-spice finish.
Best Barrel Proof Allocated Bourbon
The Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, or BTAC, began in 2000 and comes out each fall. George T. Stagg and William Larue Weller are its barrel proof bourbons, and Thomas H. Handy is its barrel proof rye. Quantities are tiny, so we don't plan around them. These are the barrel proof bottles we see more often and recommend just as happily.
A sourced Kentucky straight bourbon selected and blended under the direction of veteran distiller Jim Rutledge, bottled at cask strength. At 106.4 proof it is gentle for the category: caramel, toasted nuts and baking spice with a rich, oily texture.
Woodford's first barrel strength rye, non-chill filtered at 125.1 proof. Not a bourbon, but it is the hard-to-find bottle we'd hand to a bourbon drinker who wants more spice: rye pepper, dark fruit and cocoa. Add water.
An annual release from one of America's oldest whiskey brands, unfiltered and bottled at barrel strength. Eleven years brings toffee and old oak to the rye spice. Quantities are very small.
For more high-proof bottles, many of which are much easier to find, see our full barrel proof bourbon collection.
Best Aged and Limited Releases
These are not always the names people line up for, but they are small, limited releases that sell through, and the whiskey inside is serious.
Orphan Barrel is a line of small, limited releases of older whiskey. This one is a 17-year Kentucky straight bourbon, non-chill filtered at 92 proof. Expect old-oak dryness, dried fruit and tobacco rather than sweetness. A great gift for a whiskey drinker who loves old Scotch.
A limited Kentucky straight bourbon blend, and the last one created by former master blender John Rhea before he retired from the brand. Dark caramel, cherry and oak with real weight at 113.6 proof. This is the splurge bottle in this guide.
Not allocated in the strict sense, but a 12-year age statement at 100 proof is getting harder to find at this price. Deep oak, caramel and roasted nuts, non-chill filtered. Pair it with Baker's 13 for a great Beam tasting.
Great Bourbon That Drinks Like It's Allocated
If the bottle you want isn't in, don't leave empty-handed. Plenty of excellent bourbon is never allocated, and some of it is our own.
- Like Weller? Browse the Weller collection for what we have, or try anything in our wheated bourbon collection, starting with Old Fitzgerald or Larceny.
- Like big barrel proof bourbon? Booker's, Elijah Craig Barrel Proof and Wild Turkey Rare Breed all deliver big barrel proof flavor and are much easier to find.
- Like Blanton's? Our own single barrel picks are one-of-a-kind barrels we tasted and chose ourselves, and some of them are allocated barrel programs too.
- On a budget? Our best bourbon under $50 guide covers the everyday bottles we'd put up against anything.
How to Drink an Allocated Bottle
- Open it. Bourbon doesn't improve in the bottle. Once opened, keep it upright, sealed and out of the sun, and it will hold up well for months.
- Pour small. One ounce is plenty for a first taste, especially for barrel proof bottles.
- Add water to anything over 110 proof. A few drops at a time. The aromas open up and the heat steps back.
- Taste side by side. Weller Special Reserve next to Antique 107, or Blanton's next to Rock Hill Farms, teaches you more than any tasting note.
- Save the cocktails for the everyday bottles. E.H. Taylor Small Batch makes a great Old Fashioned. A 17-year bourbon does not need sugar and bitters.
See everything we carry from Frankfort in our Buffalo Trace Distillery collection. For the full history of Buffalo Trace's allocated lineup, the Van Winkle bottles and more, see our complete bourbon guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is allocated bourbon?
Allocated bourbon is whiskey the distiller can't make enough of, so it divides each release among distributors, who divide it among stores and bars. It is a sales practice, not a legal category.
Why is Blanton's so hard to find?
Demand is far higher than supply, and it has a huge following as a gift and collectible.
What allocated bourbon should I buy first?
Weller Special Reserve or E.H. Taylor Small Batch. Both are excellent, both sit in our $30 to $75 price tiers, and they show you the two sides of Buffalo Trace: wheated and soft, or bonded and spicy.
When does the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection come out?
BTAC is released once a year in the fall. Quantities are very small, and the proofs change with each release.
Is allocated bourbon worth it?
Often, yes, at a fair retail price. Eagle Rare 10, Weller Special Reserve and E.H. Taylor Small Batch are great whiskey for the money. At inflated resale prices, you are paying for scarcity, and there are better bottles to drink for the same spend.
Can I buy allocated bourbon online?
Yes, when we have it. Allocated bottles in stock are listed in our Allocated and Hard to Find collection, and the product page shows current availability.
Shop Allocated Bourbon at The Liquor Barn
Allocated and hard-to-find bottles while they last, plus our own single barrel picks. Ships nationwide. Family-owned since 1982.
Allocated and Hard to Find All Bourbon Our Barrel PicksThe Liquor Barn operates three retail locations in Vernon Hills, Wheeling, and Niles, Illinois. We are a licensed Illinois retailer and ship to states where direct-to-consumer alcohol shipping is permitted. Prices and availability change; the product page always has the current price. Questions about shipping to your state? Contact us here. Please drink responsibly.