Pollyanna Keep It Easy 4Pk

Pollyanna Keep It Easy 4Pk is an American Cream Ale brewed with corn and toasted coconut, packaged in a four-pack at 5.1% ABV. Produced by Pollyanna Brewing Company out of Lemont, Illinois, this sessionable ale distinguishes itself with a generous corn bill and the addition of freshly toasted coconut — an uncommon twist on a traditionally straightforward style.

Quick Facts: ABV: 5.1%  |  IBU: 18  |  Origin: Lemont, Illinois, USA  |  Style: American Cream Ale  |  Brewery: Pollyanna Brewing Company

Production & Heritage

Pollyanna Brewing Company operates out of Lemont, Illinois, with additional taproom locations in Roselle and St. Charles. Keep It Easy is built on a base of barley and a generous proportion of corn sourced from America's Heartland — a nod to the Midwest grain tradition that defines the cream ale style. What sets this expression apart from standard cream ales is the addition of freshly toasted coconut during brewing, which introduces a subtle tropical dimension without overpowering the clean, grain-forward character. The beer registers at just 18 IBUs and an SRM of 4, indicating minimal bitterness and a pale gold hue.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: Light cereal grain leads, followed by a gentle waft of toasted coconut and a faint sweetness from the corn bill. The nose is clean and inviting without heavy hop presence.

Taste: The palate opens with smooth, creamy grain — the corn contributing a soft, slightly sweet backbone. Mid-palate, toasted coconut emerges as a light, almost tropical note that adds texture and interest. The overall impression is restrained and easy-drinking, with low bitterness keeping things approachable.

Finish: Short to medium in length, with a dry, clean exit. A whisper of coconut and toasted grain lingers briefly before fading.

How to Drink Keep It Easy

Serve cold, ideally between 38–45°F, in a pint glass or pilsner glass to appreciate the golden color and light haze. This cream ale is built for straightforward drinking — no fuss required.

• Michelada: The light body and corn sweetness pair well with tomato, lime, and hot sauce in a beer cocktail format.
• Shandy: Mix with fresh lemonade to amplify the coconut's tropical lean on a warm afternoon.
• Beer Float: The coconut undertone works surprisingly well with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a dessert-style serve.

Best For

• Backyard cookouts and warm-weather sessions where low ABV matters
• Introducing craft beer drinkers to the American cream ale style
• Pairing with casual Midwest fare like grilled brats or corn on the cob
• Keeping in the fridge as a reliable, easy-drinking weeknight beer

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Keep It Easy taste like? Keep It Easy delivers a smooth, grain-forward flavor anchored by corn sweetness, with a subtle toasted coconut note adding a light tropical twist. It finishes clean and dry with very low bitterness at 18 IBUs.

How does Keep It Easy compare to Spotted Cow by New Glarus? Both are Midwest cream ales brewed with corn, but Keep It Easy incorporates freshly toasted coconut, giving it a distinct tropical undertone that Spotted Cow — a more traditionally styled farmhouse cream ale — does not have. Keep It Easy also registers slightly lower in ABV at 5.1% compared to Spotted Cow's 5.1%, making them closely matched in sessionability.

Is Keep It Easy good for beginners? Absolutely — the low IBU count, mild ABV, and clean flavor profile make it one of the more approachable craft beers available, especially for drinkers who prefer lighter styles over hop-forward ales.

Where is Keep It Easy made? Keep It Easy is brewed by Pollyanna Brewing Company, headquartered in Lemont, Illinois. Pollyanna also operates taproom locations in Roselle and St. Charles, Illinois.

What foods pair well with Keep It Easy? Grilled sweet corn complements the beer's corn-forward malt bill. Coconut shrimp echoes the toasted coconut addition. Fish tacos with lime crema match the light body and clean finish. Mild white cheddar works as a simple snack pairing, and smoked bratwurst provides a savory contrast to the subtle sweetness.

What sizes does Keep It Easy come in? Keep It Easy is available in a four-pack format, which is the standard retail offering from Pollyanna Brewing for this release.

Is Keep It Easy worth the price? Keep It Easy positions as a mid-range craft beer from a respected regional Illinois brewery. For fans of cream ales looking for something beyond the baseline style — specifically the toasted coconut addition — it represents a solid value within the Midwest craft market.

Why Keep It Easy?

American cream ales are one of the most understated styles in craft beer, and Pollyanna's version earns attention by doing something specific: adding freshly toasted coconut to an otherwise traditional corn-and-barley recipe. That single ingredient choice gives Keep It Easy a character that most cream ales lack without turning it into a novelty beer. It holds a 3.6 rating on Untappd across over 2,100 reviews, reflecting steady appreciation from a broad drinking audience. For anyone seeking a light, sessionable Midwest ale with just enough personality to stay interesting, this is a dependable choice from one of Illinois' most established craft breweries.