Liquid Love We All Scream 4Pk

Liquid Love We All Scream 4Pk is a banana split-inspired fruited sour ale from Liquid Love Brewing Co. in Wheeling, Illinois, brewed at 5.6% ABV. This dessert-driven sour layers banana, cherry, cocoa nibs, vanilla, and actual ice cream cones into one audacious can, earning a strong 3.92 rating on Untappd across nearly 200 user reviews.

Quick Facts: ABV: 5.6%  |  Origin: Wheeling, Illinois  |  Style: Fruited Sour Ale  |  Brewery: Liquid Love Brewing Co.

Production & Heritage

Liquid Love Brewing Co. operates out of 700 N Milwaukee Ave in Wheeling, Illinois, part of the greater Chicagoland craft beer scene. We All Scream falls within the brewery's adventurous lineup of dessert-inspired sours, a substyle that has surged in popularity among craft drinkers seeking bold, pastry-like flavor experiences. The base is a fruited sour ale conditioned on banana, cherry, cocoa nibs, and vanilla, with the addition of ice cream cones contributing a bready, wafer-like character that rounds out the banana split concept.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: The nose opens with ripe banana and bright maraschino cherry, followed by a subtle waft of cocoa and vanilla. It reads like a banana split before the first spoonful — sweet, fruity, and unmistakably dessert-forward.

Taste: Cherry tartness leads the entry, supported by the sour ale base that provides a sharp, puckering acidity. Mid-palate, banana sweetness and faint cocoa nibs emerge, though the fruit-forward sourness remains dominant. A bready, wafer-like quality from the ice cream cone addition surfaces toward the finish, along with a light creaminess and a candy-like sweetness some drinkers have compared to pressed sugar tablets.

Finish: Medium in length with lingering cherry tartness and a faint vanilla sweetness. The sourness recedes gradually, leaving behind a clean, slightly creamy impression.

How to Drink We All Scream

This fruited sour is best enjoyed cold, straight from the can or poured into a tulip glass to capture the full aromatic display. Its bold acidity and dessert character make it ideal as a standalone sipper rather than a cocktail ingredient. That said, adventurous drinkers have used fruited sours like this in beer floats — pairing the pour with a scoop of vanilla ice cream intensifies the banana split theme. It also works as a shandy base blended with lemonade for a tart summer drink, or as a creative substitute in a Berliner Weisse-style preparation with a dash of fruit syrup.

Best For

• Craft beer enthusiasts exploring the dessert sour category
• Summer cookouts where a conversation-starting beer steals the show
• Gifting to a friend who gravitates toward pastry stouts and fruited sours
• Dessert course pairing at a casual dinner party

Frequently Asked Questions

What does We All Scream taste like? It is a prominently tart sour ale where cherry acidity takes the lead, followed by ripe banana sweetness, faint cocoa, vanilla, and a bready ice cream cone finish. The overall impression is a drinkable, sour-forward interpretation of a banana split.

How does We All Scream compare to Drekker Brewing's banana split sours? Both target the banana split flavor profile through fruited sour bases, but We All Scream at 5.6% ABV leans into bright cherry tartness as its dominant note, whereas Drekker's smoothie-style sours tend toward thicker body and heavier fruit sweetness. The inclusion of actual ice cream cones in We All Scream adds a bready, wafer element not always present in competing versions.

Is We All Scream good for sipping on its own? Yes — its 5.6% ABV makes it sessionable enough to enjoy across an afternoon, and the complex layering of fruit, cocoa, and vanilla gives the palate plenty to explore without requiring any additions.

Where is We All Scream made? We All Scream is brewed by Liquid Love Brewing Co. at their facility on 700 N Milwaukee Ave in Wheeling, Illinois, a suburb in the Chicagoland area known for its growing craft brewing community.

What foods pair well with We All Scream? Dark chocolate brownies complement the cocoa nib character. Cheesecake with cherry topping mirrors the dominant fruit note. Grilled pork with a cherry glaze bridges savory and tart. Fresh banana bread amplifies the banana element. Vanilla bean ice cream turns the pairing into a literal banana split experience.

What sizes does We All Scream come in? It is sold as a 4-pack of cans, which is the standard retail format offered by Liquid Love Brewing Co. for this release.

Is We All Scream worth the price? We All Scream positions as a specialty craft sour ale — a niche category where small-batch production and unusual adjuncts like ice cream cones and cocoa nibs command a premium over standard sours. For fans of dessert-inspired beers, the complexity and novelty justify its placement in the upper tier of everyday craft pricing.

Why We All Scream?

What separates We All Scream from the growing crowd of dessert sours is the specificity of its recipe — banana, cherry, cocoa nibs, vanilla, and ice cream cones together reconstruct a genuine banana split rather than gesturing vaguely at sweetness. The 5.6% ABV keeps it approachable enough to drink through a full can without palate fatigue, while the sour base prevents the adjuncts from tipping into cloying territory. Its near-4.0 Untappd rating from a growing pool of reviewers signals consistent quality and broad appeal within the fruited sour community. For drinkers looking to push beyond standard fruit sours into fully realized dessert concepts, this Wheeling, Illinois release delivers on its ambitious premise.