Hop Butcher Reply Hazy Try Again 4Pk

Hop Butcher Reply Hazy Try Again 4Pk is a 7.5% ABV Double India Pale Ale from Chicago brewed with Citra, Motueka, and Simcoe hops. Rated 91 on BeerAdvocate, this hazy DIPA delivers waves of tropical citrus through a pillowy, well-carbonated body that has earned it a loyal following among hop-forward beer drinkers.

Quick Facts: ABV: 7.5%  |  Origin: Chicago, Illinois  |  Style: Double IPA  |  Brewery: Hop Butcher For The World

Production & Heritage

Hop Butcher For The World operates out of Chicago, Illinois, and has built a reputation on rotating, hop-forward releases that showcase specific hop combinations at high intensity. Reply Hazy Try Again uses a triple-hop bill of Citra, Motueka, and Simcoe — a blend that bridges American citrus punch with New Zealand's tropical character. The result is a hazy, unfiltered DIPA with a softer body than its 7.5% ABV might suggest, brewed to spotlight hop aromatics over harsh bitterness.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: Fresh-squeezed orange and pineapple lead immediately, followed by lighter notes of grapefruit, papaya, and a faint vanilla-like sweetness from the malt backbone. The aromatics are juicy and inviting without any aggressive resinous edge.

Taste: The first sip opens with ripe orange and pineapple, supported by a medium-strong sweetness that quickly transitions into a citric bitterness at mid-palate. Papaya and tropical fruit flavors layer underneath, with a light resinous hop character adding structure without overwhelming the fruit-forward profile. The malt presence is restrained, serving as a canvas rather than a co-star.

Finish: Semi-dry and moderately bitter, with a notable sweet undertone that lingers beneath the citrus. Light grapefruit emerges most clearly on the back end, giving the finish a clean, refreshing snap.

How to Drink Reply Hazy Try Again

Pour into a tulip glass or stemless wine glass at around 40–45°F to fully release the aromatic hop oils — drinking straight from the can mutes much of what makes this beer stand out. Reply Hazy Try Again is best enjoyed fresh and on its own, as the hop-forward tropical profile is the main event. Pair it alongside spicy tacos where the citrus sweetness tames the heat, with a charcuterie board where the bitterness cuts through rich, fatty meats, or with fish tacos where the tropical notes complement lime and cilantro.

Best For

• Sharing with friends during a backyard cookout or tailgate
• Introducing a craft beer drinker to Chicago's hazy IPA scene
• Pairing with bold, spicy foods like wings or street tacos
• Stocking the fridge for a weekend session with hop-forward variety

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Reply Hazy Try Again taste like? Reply Hazy Try Again delivers intense orange, pineapple, and papaya flavors backed by a medium sweetness and a moderately strong citric bitterness. The body is light and juicy with a semi-dry, refreshing finish.

How does Reply Hazy Try Again compare to other Hop Butcher DIPAs? Hop Butcher releases a rotating lineup of hazy IPAs and DIPAs, each defined by a specific hop combination; Reply Hazy Try Again is distinguished by its Citra, Motueka, and Simcoe blend, which leans more tropical and less piney than some of the brewery's Mosaic- or Galaxy-driven releases.

Is Reply Hazy Try Again good for sipping on its own? Absolutely — the balanced sweetness-to-bitterness ratio and juicy tropical character make it highly drinkable as a standalone pour, especially when served cold in a proper glass.

Where is Reply Hazy Try Again made? Reply Hazy Try Again is brewed by Hop Butcher For The World in Chicago, Illinois, a brewery known for its rotating roster of hop-centric ales distributed primarily across the Midwest.

What foods pair well with Reply Hazy Try Again? Spicy chicken wings work well because the citrus sweetness tempers the heat. Fish tacos complement the tropical hop character. Aged cheddar contrasts the bitterness with rich, sharp fat. A burger with pepper jack cheese mirrors the beer's bold intensity. Fresh ceviche echoes the bright citrus notes naturally.

What sizes does Reply Hazy Try Again come in? Reply Hazy Try Again is commonly available as a 4-pack of 16 oz cans, which is the standard format for Hop Butcher's DIPA releases.

Is Reply Hazy Try Again worth the price? Reply Hazy Try Again positions in the premium craft DIPA tier, and its 91-point BeerAdvocate score alongside a 4.2 rating on Untappd from nearly 12,000 reviews suggests strong value relative to other limited-run hazy DIPAs in its class.

Why Reply Hazy Try Again?

The specific combination of Citra, Motueka, and Simcoe creates a hop profile that bridges American citrus intensity with New Zealand tropical fruit character — a blend not commonly found in the saturated hazy DIPA market. A 91-point BeerAdvocate rating and over 11,600 Untappd reviews confirm this isn't just hype; it consistently delivers. Hop Butcher's approach of building each release around a tightly curated hop bill means Reply Hazy Try Again has a defined identity rather than a kitchen-sink approach to hopping. For drinkers who want a juicy, fruit-forward double IPA with genuine complexity and a clean finish, this Chicago-brewed four-pack earns its reputation.