George Remus Gatsby Reserve Bourbon 15 Year 750ML

George Remus Gatsby Reserve Bourbon 15 Year 750ML is a cask-strength, 15-year-old straight bourbon whiskey bottled at 102.8 proof (51.4% ABV) in a 750ml bottle. This release earned a Double Gold medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition and was named to Robb Report's prestigious list of 50 Greatest Bourbons.

Quick Facts: ABV: 51.4% (102.8 Proof)  |  Origin: Lawrenceburg, Indiana, USA  |  15 Year Age Statement  |  Distillery: Ross & Squibb Distillery

Production & Heritage

Gatsby Reserve is produced at Ross & Squibb Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Indiana — a facility with deep roots in American whiskey distilling, now operated by MGP. What distinguishes this expression is the blending of two distinct mashbills: a 75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley recipe alongside a higher-rye 60% corn, 36% rye, 4% malted barley recipe. Hand-selected 15-year-old barrels from the distillery's reserves are married together at cask strength, and the 2025 release lands at 102.8 proof — notably higher than the 2022 and 2023 editions, which hovered around 98 proof and drew attention for their uncommon approachability at that age.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: The nose opens with caramelized sugar, vanilla icing, and dark chocolate before settling into deeper layers of old leather, cigar box, and damp forest floor. Dried berries and cherry liqueur emerge alongside toasted pecan and musty oak, recalling the scent of leather-bound books.

Taste: The entry is rich with maple syrup and blackstrap molasses, quickly joined by candied pecan, toffee, and milk chocolate. Mid-palate, baking spice — cinnamon, nutmeg — weaves through orchard fruit notes of baked apple and pear, while a persistent rye pepper backbone and firm oak tannin provide structure. Bright citrus notes of orange and lemon add unexpected freshness beneath the darker flavors of cherry cola and tobacco.

Finish: Long and layered, the finish moves through walnut, roasted almond, and fig, anchored by lingering oak and a faint wisp of smoke. The interplay of sweetness and rye spice stays present well after the final sip fades.

How to Drink Gatsby Reserve

At 102.8 proof, Gatsby Reserve rewards patient sipping neat, though a few drops of water open up the orchard fruit and chocolate notes without diminishing the oak backbone. For cocktail applications, the 15-year depth and dual-mashbill complexity translate well: try it in a Manhattan, where the rye spice and dark fruit amplify sweet vermouth beautifully; an Old Fashioned, where the toffee and baking spice need only minimal sweetening; or a Boulevardier, where the bold proof and chocolate notes stand up to Campari's bitterness.

Best For

• Gifting a serious bourbon collector who values age-stated, cask-strength releases
• Anchoring a side-by-side tasting of aged Indiana bourbons
• Celebrating a milestone — anniversary, promotion, or retirement
• Building a curated home bar shelf of award-winning American whiskey

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Gatsby Reserve taste like? Gatsby Reserve delivers a rich, full-bodied profile dominated by toffee, maple syrup, baking spice, and dark chocolate, layered over firm oak tannin and persistent rye pepper. Orchard fruit notes of baked apple and pear, plus hints of cherry cola and tobacco, add complexity throughout.

How does Gatsby Reserve compare to Remus Repeal Reserve? Remus Repeal Reserve is a younger, more approachable blend designed as an annual limited release, while Gatsby Reserve occupies the ultra-premium tier with a 15-year age statement and cask-strength bottling. The additional aging in Gatsby Reserve contributes significantly more oak depth, leather, and dried fruit complexity than the Repeal Reserve typically delivers.

Is Gatsby Reserve good for sipping neat? Absolutely — the 15-year maturation produces a well-integrated bourbon where the cask-strength proof (102.8) enhances rather than overwhelms the layered toffee, spice, and oak character. A small addition of water can further unlock fruit and chocolate nuances.

Where is Gatsby Reserve made? Gatsby Reserve is distilled and aged at Ross & Squibb Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, a historic American whiskey facility situated along the Ohio River in the heart of the Indiana bourbon-producing region.

What foods pair well with Gatsby Reserve? Dark chocolate truffles complement the cocoa and toffee notes; smoked brisket mirrors the whiskey's oak and leather character; pecan pie amplifies the candied nut sweetness; aged Gouda brings out the caramel undertones; and a charcuterie board with dried figs and roasted almonds echoes the finish.

What sizes does Gatsby Reserve come in? Gatsby Reserve is available in the standard 750ml bottle size.

Is Gatsby Reserve worth the price? Gatsby Reserve positions firmly in the ultra-premium bourbon tier, justified by its 15-year age statement, cask-strength proof, dual-mashbill blending, and strong critical recognition including a Double Gold at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition and inclusion on Robb Report's 50 Greatest Bourbons list.

Why Gatsby Reserve?

In a category where many 15-year bourbons rely on a single mashbill, Gatsby Reserve distinguishes itself by marrying barrels from two distinct rye-forward recipes — 21% and 36% rye — creating a layered complexity that neither could achieve alone. The 2025 release at 102.8 proof represents a meaningful step up in intensity from prior editions that bottled closer to 98 proof, giving experienced drinkers more to work with. Recognition from the San Francisco World Spirits Competition (Double Gold), the International Spirits Challenge (Gold), and the American Spirits Council of Tasters (Platinum, Ascot Awards) confirms this expression competes at the highest level of aged American whiskey. For collectors and enthusiasts seeking a cask-strength Indiana bourbon with serious age and verified accolades, Gatsby Reserve sets a clear benchmark.