Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey 750ML

Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey 750ML is a flavored Tennessee corn whiskey bottled at 30% ABV (60 proof) in a 750ml bottle. It earned a Double Gold distinction at the 2023 PR%F Awards and scored 93 points from Tastings.com, placing it among the highest-rated entries in the peanut butter whiskey category.

Quick Facts: ABV: 30%  |  Origin: Gatlinburg, Tennessee, USA  |  2-Year Aged Corn Whiskey Base  |  Distillery: Ole Smoky Distillery

Production & Heritage

Ole Smoky Distillery opened in 2010 as Tennessee's first federally licensed distillery in Gatlinburg, initially gaining fame for its moonshine lineup before expanding into whiskey. The Peanut Butter expression starts with a corn whiskey distilled from an 84% corn, 8% rye, and 8% malted barley mashbill, then aged for two years. What separates it from many flavored competitors is the use of real peanut oil in production, contributing an authentically nutty character rather than a purely artificial sweetness.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: Roasted peanuts hit first, followed by soft caramel and a subtle graham cracker quality. There is a gentle sweetness underneath, reminiscent of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich straight from the jar.

Taste: The entry is creamy and moderately sweet, with unmistakable peanut butter coating the palate immediately. At mid-palate, caramel and toffee emerge alongside vanilla, while the underlying corn whiskey backbone provides just enough structure to keep it grounded. The mouthfeel is notably thick and glycerous, landing closer to fresh roasted peanuts than candy-like sweetness.

Finish: Medium in length with a slightly warming quality. Lingering peanut butter and a gentle nuttiness fade gradually, leaving behind traces of toasted grain and light sweetness.

How to Drink Ole Smoky Peanut Butter

Served chilled or on the rocks, the whiskey's creamy texture and moderate proof make it immediately approachable. A splash of cream turns it into a simple dessert sipper on its own.

• Peanut Butter Old Fashioned — the nutty richness pairs naturally with bitters and a touch of maple syrup, adding depth to a classic template.
• PB&J Cocktail — shake with raspberry or blackberry liqueur and lemon juice for a balanced riff on the childhood staple.
• Nutty Espresso Martini — combine with cold brew coffee and coffee liqueur, where the peanut oil's creaminess amplifies the drink's body.

Best For

• Introducing whiskey-curious drinkers to the category through an accessible flavor profile
• Building a dessert cocktail menu at home with a versatile flavored base
• Gifting someone who appreciates creative Tennessee whiskey expressions
• After-dinner sipping as a stand-alone dessert alternative

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Ole Smoky Peanut Butter taste like? It delivers a creamy, authentic peanut butter flavor upfront, layered with caramel, toffee, and vanilla, finishing with a medium-length nutty warmth. The mouthfeel is thick and moderately sweet rather than cloying.

How does Ole Smoky Peanut Butter compare to Skrewball? Skrewball is widely regarded as the original peanut butter whiskey and tends to lean sweeter with a liqueur-like body, while Ole Smoky uses a defined corn whiskey base with an 84% corn mashbill aged two years, giving it a more noticeable grain backbone. Ole Smoky also incorporates real peanut oil, which contributes a more natural roasted-nut character.

Is Ole Smoky Peanut Butter good for cocktails? At 30% ABV it mixes easily without overpowering other ingredients, and its creamy texture makes it particularly well-suited for dessert cocktails, shaken drinks, and coffee-based builds.

Where is Ole Smoky Peanut Butter made? It is produced at Ole Smoky Distillery in Gatlinburg, Tennessee, in the foothills of the Great Smoky Mountains. The distillery has been operating since 2010 and is one of Tennessee's most visited.

What foods pair well with Ole Smoky Peanut Butter? Dark chocolate brownies complement its nutty sweetness. Apple slices with caramel dip echo the whiskey's toffee and fruit notes. Banana bread intensifies the creamy, baked quality. Vanilla ice cream creates a simple affogato-style dessert. A cheese plate featuring aged gouda or sharp cheddar provides a savory counterpoint.

What sizes does Ole Smoky Peanut Butter come in? The standard size is 750ml, and it is also commonly available in 50ml miniatures and 375ml half-bottles.

Is Ole Smoky Peanut Butter worth the price? It positions as an accessible, entry-level flavored whiskey that punches above its price tier in quality — the 93-point Tastings.com score and Double Gold at the 2023 PR%F Awards suggest strong value relative to other peanut butter whiskeys on the market.

Why Ole Smoky Peanut Butter?

The use of real peanut oil in the production process is the single most important differentiator here, delivering a roasted-nut authenticity that synthetic flavorings struggle to replicate. Built on a two-year-aged corn whiskey with a clearly defined 84% corn mashbill, this is not simply a sweetened spirit — there is actual whiskey character beneath the peanut butter. The 93-point score from Tastings.com and Double Gold at the 2023 PR%F Awards confirm that the execution holds up under scrutiny. For anyone exploring the peanut butter whiskey category, this Tennessee-made expression provides a genuine, well-structured alternative to sweeter competitors.