Midnight Moonshake Peanut Butter 750ML

Midnight Moonshake Peanut Butter 750ML is a moonshine-based cream liqueur bottled at 17% ABV (34 proof) in a 750ml format. Produced by Piedmont Distillers in Madison, North Carolina, this expression draws direct inspiration from the golden age of American diners, combining corn moonshine with rich peanut butter and chocolate cream flavors in a category that remains relatively uncommon.

Quick Facts: ABV: 17%  |  Origin: Madison, North Carolina, USA  |  Style: Moonshine Cream Liqueur  |  Distillery: Piedmont Distillers

Production & Heritage

Piedmont Distillers, based in Madison, North Carolina, is recognized as the first legal distillery in the state and the producer behind the Midnight Moon brand. The Moonshake line uses a base spirit distilled from 100% American corn and handcrafted in small batches, then blended with real vanilla cream and natural flavors. What separates the Peanut Butter expression from the broader Midnight Moon portfolio is its dessert-forward identity — rather than presenting as a flavored spirit, it lands squarely in cream liqueur territory, with moonshine providing the backbone instead of the more typical neutral grain spirit or whiskey base found in competing products.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: Roasted peanuts lead the nose immediately, followed by layers of vanilla cream and a gentle caramel sweetness. There is a subtle grain note underneath that hints at the corn moonshine base without overpowering the dessert character.

Taste: The entry is sweet and nutty, with rich peanut butter dominating the front palate. At mid-palate, soft milk chocolate notes emerge alongside a velvety vanilla cream that adds body and rounds out the sweetness. Warm moonshine undertones surface toward the peak, providing just enough spirit presence to keep this from reading as purely confectionery.

Finish: The finish is long, creamy, and slightly nutty, with lingering peanut butter and a faint caramel-like sweetness trailing off. The texture remains smooth throughout, with no harsh alcohol burn despite the moonshine foundation.

How to Drink Midnight Moonshake

Served chilled or over ice, this cream liqueur is at its best when the cold temperature tightens the sweetness and lets the peanut butter and chocolate notes come into sharper focus. It also works well as a component in cocktails:

• Peanut Butter Cup Martini — Shake with chocolate liqueur and a splash of cream for a dessert cocktail that leans into the existing flavor profile.
• Nutty White Russian — Substitute Moonshake for the traditional cream component alongside coffee liqueur and vodka; the peanut butter adds an unexpected savory-sweet layer.
• Moonshake Float — Pour over a scoop of vanilla or chocolate ice cream for a boozy milkshake that plays directly into the diner-inspired concept.

Best For

• After-dinner drinks when a full dessert course feels unnecessary
• Gifting to someone who gravitates toward peanut butter or dessert-flavored spirits
• Building a themed cocktail menu for a casual gathering or game-day party
• Introducing friends to flavored spirits who find standard whiskey or moonshine too intense

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Midnight Moonshake Peanut Butter taste like? It tastes like a liquid peanut butter cup — rich roasted peanut butter up front, soft milk chocolate and vanilla cream in the middle, and a warm moonshine undertone that adds just enough spirit character to remind you it is a liqueur, not a milkshake.

How does Midnight Moonshake compare to Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey? Skrewball is a flavored whiskey bottled at 35% ABV with a more prominent spirit backbone, while Midnight Moonshake is a cream liqueur at 17% ABV built on a corn moonshine base with added chocolate and vanilla cream. Moonshake is notably sweeter, lower in proof, and more dessert-oriented than Skrewball.

Is Midnight Moonshake good for beginners? At 17% ABV with a sweet, creamy profile, it is one of the most approachable flavored spirits available and a strong entry point for anyone who finds standard liquor too harsh or spirit-forward.

Where is Midnight Moonshake made? Midnight Moonshake is produced by Piedmont Distillers in Madison, North Carolina, the first legal distillery in the state. The base moonshine is distilled from 100% American corn.

What foods pair well with Midnight Moonshake? Dark chocolate truffles mirror the existing chocolate notes and add bittersweet contrast. Salted pretzels play off the peanut butter with a savory crunch. Banana bread bridges the nutty sweetness with baked fruit warmth. Vanilla cheesecake echoes the cream base without competing. Candied bacon introduces a smoky-sweet element that complements the caramel undertones.

What sizes does Midnight Moonshake come in? The standard and most widely available size is the 750ml bottle.

Is Midnight Moonshake worth the price? Midnight Moonshake positions as an accessible, entry-level cream liqueur. At 17% ABV, the price-per-proof is modest, and it delivers a highly specific flavor experience that is difficult to replicate by simply mixing spirits with cream at home.

Why Midnight Moonshake?

What gives the Peanut Butter expression its identity is the corn moonshine base — a departure from the whiskey or neutral grain spirit foundations used by most cream liqueurs and flavored spirits in this space. Piedmont Distillers brings legitimate distilling heritage to what could otherwise read as a novelty product, grounding the dessert flavors in a regional spirit tradition. The lower ABV makes it versatile enough for both standalone sipping and cocktail building without overwhelming a drink. For anyone looking for a peanut butter spirit that leans toward indulgent creaminess rather than whiskey heat, this is the clearest expression of that concept currently on the market.